← My Auto Racer Comparisons All cars
A 410 Nm diesel against a 280 Nm hot hatch, and why the one with less torque wins. How to read a performance specification without making the three unit mistakes that catch everybody.
A 2003 BMW 330d makes 410 Nm. A 2004 Golf GTI makes 280 Nm — 46 per cent less. The GTI is the quicker car, by 0.44 s over a quarter mile. Engine torque is not the force that moves a car, and on its own it predicts almost nothing.
Simulated on this site from each car's published power, mass, gearing and drag.
Engine torque is measured at the crankshaft. Between the crankshaft and the road there is a gearbox, a final drive and a tyre, and every one of them changes the number. By the time the engine's effort reaches the tarmac it has been multiplied by the gear ratio, multiplied again by the final drive, reduced by driveline losses, and then divided by the radius of the tyre. The figure in the brochure has been through four transformations before it does anything useful.
So the honest version of the question is not “how much torque does the engine make?” but “how much force reaches the road, at the speed I care about?” Those are different quantities with different units, and the second one is the one that accelerates the car.
Power is torque multiplied by rotational speed:
P = τ × ω where ω = rpm × 2π ÷ 60
They are not independent. Quoting both as though they were two separate virtues of an engine is the first mistake. Run the 330d's own figures through it:
Both statements are true at once, and neither contradicts the brochure. Peak torque and peak power are simply different points on the same curve.
The conversion itself is exact and dull:
1 lbf·ft = 1.35582 N·m
| Figure | N·m | lb-ft |
|---|---|---|
| BMW 330d (E46, 2003) | 410 | 302.4 |
| VW Golf GTI (Mk5, 2004) | 280 | 206.5 |
Three things go wrong far more often than the arithmetic:
Here is the 330d's 410 Nm, unchanged, through four different gears. The ratios below are illustrative — a plausible six-speed with a 3.46 final drive and a 0.32 m rolling radius — because the point is the spread, not the car:
F = τengine × igear × ifinal × η ÷ rwheel
| Gear | Ratio | Wheel torque (N·m) | Force at the road |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | 3.50 | 4965 | 13189 N |
| 2nd | 2.10 | 2979 | 7913 N |
| 4th | 1.00 | 1419 | 3768 N |
| 6th | 0.85 | 1206 | 3203 N |
One engine, one torque figure, and a 4.1× difference in how hard the car pushes. Any statement of the form “410 Nm means it pulls hard” is missing the only variables that decide the answer.
Gear ratios are rarely to hand. There is a way round them. Power is conserved across the driveline apart from losses, so force at the road at a given speed is:
F = P × η ÷ v
Engine torque has vanished from that equation. At any given road speed, the hardest a car can push is set by its power and the speed it is already doing — the gearbox's job is to let the engine sit where the power is. This is why power, not torque, predicts acceleration, and why the gearbox is the thing that converts one into the other.
Both cars at 100 km/h (27.78 m/s), assuming 0.85 driveline efficiency and that each is in the right gear to make full power:
| BMW 330d (E46, 2003) | VW Golf GTI (Mk5, 2004) | |
|---|---|---|
| Engine torque | 410 Nm (302.4 lb-ft) | 280 Nm (206.5 lb-ft) |
| Power | 150 kW (201 hp) | 147 kW (197 hp) |
| Mass | 1540 kg | 1303 kg |
| Force at 100 km/h | 4590 N | 4498 N |
| Acceleration there | 2.98 m/s² | 3.45 m/s² |
| 0–60 mph, simulated | 7.37 s | 6.80 s |
| Quarter mile, simulated | 15.65 s at 93.2 mph | 15.21 s at 95.0 mph |
The diesel brings 46 per cent more engine torque and arrives at the road with less force per kilogram. Its power is within 2 per cent of the GTI's, and it is carrying 237 kg more car. Both figures in the last two rows come from this site's simulator, running the same published power, mass, gearing and drag that produced the rest of the table.
Run it yourself: BMW 330d vs Golf GTI, or swap either car for any of about 15,000.
It is not useless, it is just answering a different question. A large torque figure low in the rev range means the engine makes usable force without being revved, which is most of normal driving: pulling away, overtaking in the gear you are already in, towing. That is a real quality and it is what people mean when they say a diesel “feels” strong. It is simply not the same question as which car is quicker, and the two answers often point in opposite directions.
The acceleration figures here are computed, not measured. Each car is simulated from its published kerb mass, rated power, drivetrain and gearing, then fitted to its own published acceleration figures; both cars run in identical conditions, so the comparison between them holds even though no single time is a timing slip. The torque and power figures are the manufacturers' published ratings for the specific model years named — which matters here, because the earlier 184 hp 330d makes 390 Nm, not 410.